Choosing a cake sounds easy until you realise how many options are out there. Different flavours, sizes, designs, dietary needs and delivery cutoffs can turn a fun decision into a stressful one. Ice cream cakes solve a lot of those problems. They’re flexible, crowd-friendly, and ideal for warm weather parties or anyone who wants something less traditional.
If you’re deciding between styles, designer cakes and themed options make it easy to match the vibe of your event. Here’s how to pick the right one for your next celebration.
Who Is the Cake For?
Age, personality and the type of event all help narrow things down. Kids tend to love bright characters and shapes. Adults may want something more minimal, or a photo cake with a personal image. If you’re planning a work event or group gathering, a neutral design with mixed flavours usually works best.
Superhero cakes are a go-to for younger guests, but there is also a range of sports, pop culture and customisable options if you want something more specific.
Choosing the Right Cake Size for Your Guest List
A 1.3L cake feeds 8 to 12. A 2.2L serves 16 to 20. Go bigger if the cake is your only dessert or if you want leftovers. Ice cream cakes hold well in the freezer and do not go stale, so ordering up is not a problem.
Ready made cakes are ideal if you’re pressed for time or need an easy pick based on headcount.
Mixing Flavours for a Crowd-Pleasing Result
Most cakes let you choose up to three flavours. Chocolate and vanilla are safe picks, but a layered combo makes the cake more interesting. Fruity flavours tend to work well in summer. Something richer like cookies and cream or hazelnut suits winter events or evening functions.
You can check out the flavour list if you’re looking for ideas before ordering.
The Impact of Design and Theme
Think about what the cake will look like on the table or in the photos. A unicorn, footy or Pokémon cake adds character to a kid’s party. A minimalist design can blend into a work setting or grown-up birthday. Photo cakes also work across age groups, especially for milestones.
There are novelty cakes in just about every theme you can think of, including vehicles, animals, movies and TV.
Why Ice Cream Cakes Stand Out From Sponge Cakes?
Ice cream cakes offer more flavour options, store better and stay fresh for weeks in the freezer. They are also a cooler choice for summer events, and they tend to get stronger visual reactions from guests.
Unlike a sponge, you do not have to worry about drying out. They just need to be served at the right moment, slightly softened.
Catering to Dietary Needs Without the Stress
It is smart to ask your guests ahead of time. Many of our cakes are nut free, gluten free or dairy free. Ingredient transparency matters, especially for school events or parties where kids have allergies.
If you are unsure, just mention it when ordering. We will help you pick something safe.
When to Order and What to Do If You’re in a Rush
Custom orders need lead time. But if you are on a tight schedule, there is a same-day click and collect range available. It includes popular designs, prepped and ready to go.
If you’re in Melbourne, most suburbs are covered. Delivery runs Monday to Saturday and includes insulation to keep the cake frozen during transit. You can find full suburb coverage and times in the delivery and pickup guide.
Seasonal and Limited-Edition Options Worth Considering
You will see themed options around major events and holidays like footy finals, Christmas or school break specials. These rotate often and tend to sell quickly.
New designs and seasonal offerings are regularly featured on the Birthday Cake Shop homepage, making it easy to find something unique for your next celebration.
Order the Perfect Ice Cream Cake for Your Next Celebration
Whether you’re planning or need something today, explore our customisable options through the Cake Builder or pick from our Ready Made Cakes.
Not sure what to choose?
Our friendly team is here to help. Get in touch, and we will help you celebrate deliciously.
Reach out to our friendly team for delicious celebratory assistance.
